Should I notify the Insurance Company after an Accident? Yes, you should always notify your insurance company of any accidents. You can notify the other insurance company, the adverse or defendant insurance company, or you can let us do it, which we prefer. But yes, you should always notify all the insurance people involved. I would NOT give a statement to any insurance company, even your own necessarily, because you may have uninsured motorist or PIP, or you may have different things. They’re supposed to be on your side, but they may not necessarily be on your side. So at least if you have a lawyer there on your and the insurance company is asking unfair questions, or leading questions, or questions that suggest a wrong answer or could be construed wrong, you can have a lawyer there to object.